Man, do you remember back in 2005 when Wolfmother dropped their debut album? That glorious mix of proggy, organ-drenched, chunky guitar goodness that reminded us that Uriah Heep were pretty cool(at least Ken Hensley’s bits) and that Robert Plant would’ve sounded pretty damn cool fronting Black Sabbath. Yeah, I remember that self-titled well. There was plenty of folks yelling from the rafters that Wolfmother were nothing more than hacky wannabes regurgitating what we’d all digested over the course of 40 years of garage, psych, stoner, and heavy metal musical history. Well to them I say “Back off, man!” Regardless what Andrew Stockdale, Chris Ross, and Myles Heskett were regurgitating or what they were derivative of, it worked. Great riffs, catchy hooks, and serious grooves. Well then in 2008 Wolfmother’s rhythm section said adios and left Stockdale to fend for himself and take all the heat for the band splintering.
Here we are in 2016 and here we are talking about a new Wolfmother album called Victorious. This is Andrew Stockdale’s fourth album under the Wolfmother moniker, following Cosmic Egg and New Crown. Victorious is the weakest yet. Here’s the thing, I don’t think any of the records released after that self-titled debut have been Wolfmother records. They’ve been Andrew Stockdale records. I think if you look at them, as well as this new one, as solo LPs that grading curve can be manipulated a bit. As an Andrew Stockdale album Victorious is okay. As a Wolfmother album it’s a rehash of a rehash.
Victorious has got a little bit of everything on it. Big, meaty, gas guzzling rockers like “The Love That You Give”, “Baroness”, and “Happy Face”. These songs are cleaner, crisper, and sort of thinner shadows of that massive sound Stockdale made with Heskett and Ross back in 2005. While not as visceral as Wolfmother of yore, they’re still fun for a bit. “City Lights”, “Gypsy Caravan”, and “Eye of the Beholder” are second tier rock. They sound like retreads of older songs that were retreads to begin with. A copy of a copy of copy. After your first run thru you’ll be hitting the skip button. Then you’ve got overproduced tracks like “Victorious”, “Pretty Peggy”, and “Best Of A Bad Situation” that feel like they’re pandering to Kings of Leon fans, complete with “oohs” and “ahhs” in the choruses and hand claps scattered about so the arena crowds will have something to do besides yawn at the shows.
I’m not sure why Andrew Stockdale is still calling this band Wolfmother. It’s not Wolfmother. Wolfmother was those three guys that put out songs like “Colossal”, “White Unicorn”, and “Woman”. Those three guys could’ve taken Wolfmother into new territory. New dimensions. Instead, we’ve got the singer with a backing band playing cover band versions of that first great record. As an Andrew Stockdale record Victorious is understandable. As a Wolfmother record Victorious is anything but.
5.5 out 10
Thank you. I almost bought this yesterday. Now maybe I won’t.
I do like Victorious though.
LikeLiked by 1 person
If you can stream it somewhere do. At least then you’ve got an idea whether or not you’d listen more than once. It would collect dust in my collection unfortunately.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great review Mr H, I loved their debut and they were incredible live back then too.
This sounds kinda sad overall, great LP cover though.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Did you get to see them with the original three? I would have loved to see them back then as well.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yup, about a year after the debut was released. They were really, really loud. my mate who is hipper than me saw them play in a tiny club before the first LP came out.
LikeLiked by 3 people
That sounds fantastic.
LikeLiked by 3 people
One of the main reasons I almost bought it on vinyl was the beautiful cover.
It might even catch my eye sone day enough to buy it. Perhaps in the used section.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Sometimes a negative review is the only authentic response (other than not reviewing at all). I certainly find it valid for a new release, so thanks JH. Reminds me to watch out for the debut.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Had I not been a fan from the get go I probably wouldn’t have bothered, but I was a huge fan of the first album. I don’t blame Mr. Stockdale for continuing on, it’s just not my thing.
If you haven’t heard the debut, give it a listen sometime.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I will. There’s something very comforting about retro-driven contemporary rock when it’s well done. Last week I re-visited the first Standarte album; Atomic Rooster meets Black Sabbath!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Standarte sounds intriguing. I must investigate.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I did a quick search for Standarte and cd and vinyl both go for hundreds of dollars. 😦
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow.
LikeLike
Oh man. I haven’t enjoyed any of the Wolfmother albums since that first one. Actually can’t believe it was that long ago! But definitely a case of diminishing returns.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Diminishing returns. Exactly!
LikeLike